three rivers catahoulas wrote:I guess I'm old fashioned, but I like to start with a pup, I have never baught a finished dog that some one eles has trained. I think you get a better dog out of one that you have raised. .
I have done a lot of both. I started out with pups, and if you are hunting in snow, you can train up a pup by walking him on bobcat tracks, and getting him broke off trash. It is really really hard work, and extremely time consuming, but you will get an college course on bobcats by keeping your pup on a leash while you do all the cold trailing.
This is the most amazing training technique I know of, and the dogs I have trained this way have all been above average. You can constantly be teaching the dog about every track of every animal, every animal sighted, and every situation wether rocks, rivers, roads or traps. You are a true mentor, and beleive me, your pup is paying attention to you. If you have the type dog that wants to please you, this is extremely powerful training. He will learn everything that pleases you and everything that does not. Talk to him a lot, and tell him what is good and what is bad. Let your emotions show, and maybe over-exagerate them a bit if you encounter off game or traps.
I definately understand three rivers catahoulas position. Recently, I was looking back on all the dogs I have owned and evaluating them. Among the adult dogs I have purchased (and some for a rediculous amount of money), there is not one that made my list of favorite dogs. All my best dogs were raised from pups.
From my perspective, the biggest problem with raising from a pup, is there are just a lot of pups that will not make bobcat dogs even when given the best of training. It is heart breaking to raise up a pup, and then make the slow painful realization that the pup will never make a comlete bobcat dog.
This might be one reason why most of my cats have been caught with a team of two dogs. I end up with a well trained dog that is lacking in certain areas, then I go looking for the dog that is strong in those areas, but might be weak where the other dog is strong. When the two dogs click together, it can be, (and has been), deadly. Very deadly.
It's hard to admit, but I have never owned a bobcat dog that was complete in every way, Yet I have caught a lot of game using pairs of dogs that compliment each other.
I recomend the pup pathway, just because you can get out, have some fun, and learn an awful lot about the game you are after. It is a long hard way to go, but sometimes the long hard way is better than the short easy way. If you miss out on the great experience of deep bonding and mutual trust with a dog, then, in my opinion, you miss out on what helps make this one of the greatest sports there is.
Whatever you do, just have fun out there, dont forget about your family, and remember: they are still just dogs.