Looking at Plotts

larry · Post by **larry** » Thu Jun 19, 2008 3:21 am

Catch wrote:Has anyone hunted with the Bloody Bill dog of Greg's? Just curious of what you thought. Maybe PM me with your opinion.

Sounds like you are a skeptic, if you have deep enough pockets or think your dogs can handle it, pretty sure Bill's owner is willing to put up $5000 on any big game animal bear lion bob to any dog that can show up and out do him. This is what I have been told not sure if its a solid fact or not, but it came from someone that would know, so I guess you have the opportunity to go hunt with him and see for yourself. I hope you find the answers that you keep indirectly digging for about Greg's dogs, Azplott on this board has a bunch of em too and will tell you alot more of an earfull than I or anyone else here has.

three rivers catahoulas · Thu Jun 19, 2008 10:59 am

People can disagree, I guess thats the good thing about it. But all I was tellin the kid was what I thought and thats the way I see it granted most dogs give a lot of respect to them bear on the ground! I just haven't had one of those dog yet I guess. most of the dogs that I have that are my hog dogs are most of the time realy rough bear dogs and thats just the way I've seen it. But to brotch the topic of one have to be tougher then the other. On average 96% of the bear ran in this state will go up a tree the rest your probly gonna get on the ground. Would ya like to tell me how many hogs go up a tree anywere?

Catch · Post by **Catch** » Thu Jun 19, 2008 6:34 pm

So Larry have you hunted with the dog or not?

I would like to get some opinions on the dog from people that has hunted with him.

The Internet is a great thing, dogs become famous before they are born and get real good after they die.

Why would the owner offer $5,000.00 and not $500.00? Maybe because it limits the amount of takers.

Andy Drumm · Post by **Andy Drumm** » Thu Jun 19, 2008 6:48 pm

MARSHAL , YOU DONT EVEN KNOW HOW THE SMITHDEAL SITE IS .. YOU HAVE NOT BEEN ON THAT SITE FOR 2 YEARS OR SO .. THERE IS PLENTY OF EXPERIANCED HUNTERS .. SOME WITH MORE YEARS BEAR HUNTING THAN I HAVE BEEN ALIVE..
I DONT CARE WHAT PROBLEMS YOU HAVE HAD WITH MEMBERS OF THE SITE NOR DO I CARE .. IT IS NOT A STRAIN BLIND SITE .. I HAVE BEEN ASKING FOR PEDIGREES AND PICTURES FROM ANY LINE OF DOGS .. ITS A GREAT SITE JUST LIKE MOST OTHERS ARE ..

WHY DO YOU HIDE BEHIND MADE UP NAMES WHEN YOU POST STUFF LIKE YOU DO .. CONSTANTLY RUNNING DOWN OTHERS DOGS , THEIR DOGS HUNTING ABILTY ,THEIR OWN HUNTING ABILITY .. TALKING CRAP ABOUT THINGS YOU JUST KNOW NOTHING ABOUT ??
OR IF THE SMITHDEAL SITE IS SO BAD WHY HAVE YOU TRIED TO RE-REGISTER ?? STILL USING FAKE NAMES TO TRY TO DO SO ??

Catch · Post by **Catch** » Thu Jun 19, 2008 9:25 pm

Mr. Drumm, since your more interested in the Smithdeal Society than Plotts I'm going to explain a couple of things. First, I do know what happens on that site and who is on it. I read it whenever I want and you will never figure out how. The site is very quiet for all the "EXPERIENCED" guys that never post. Please don't flatter yourself with the idea I try to keep registering when I have never stopped reading! LOL

The rest of your post is gibberish, if you want you can load up your pack
and we can go catch a few.

Oh, one more thing, if you ever want to talk Plotts or go hunting PM me. Please stop wasting my time with these childhood games of yours.

Take Care Andy!

larry · Post by **larry** » Thu Jun 19, 2008 10:03 pm

Catch wrote:So Larry have you hunted with the dog or not?

I would like to get some opinions on the dog from people that has hunted with him.

The Internet is a great thing, dogs become famous before they are born and get real good after they die.

Why would the owner offer $5,000.00 and not $500.00? Maybe because it limits the amount of takers.

Never have, but I have seen video of him and personally seen alot of his pups and own his daughter and grandson. Plott Proud had a full brother to him that was killed by a bear and recently bred a female to anothr full brother of his. He is out of Cody II and Mississippi Mud Dozer. I think there was a taker on that $5000, but you would have to ask his owner to be sure. The internet had nothing to do with the popularity of this dog. He is just now getting mentioned and that is due to his offspring and his father and the fact that he is an outstanding plott, all on his own. He doesn't need the internets help getting the job done, neither do his pups. This thread was started to get peoples opinions on outstanding plott dogs, not for you to come on here and try to take something away from great dogs.

Catch · Post by **Catch** » Thu Jun 19, 2008 10:35 pm

Larry, if possible you need to hunt with the dog!

Andy Drumm · Post by **Andy Drumm** » Thu Jun 19, 2008 11:34 pm

WELL OKAY .. LOL

Smiley · Post by **Smiley** » Fri Jun 20, 2008 2:21 am

I was told that the same guy bought Negrey ( sp?) and that Negrey was in some areas better than Bill.

larry · Post by **larry** » Fri Jun 20, 2008 2:25 am

Catch wrote:Larry, if possible you need to hunt with the dog!

I'd love too, but I guess his son and daughter will have to do for now. Have you hunted with the dog? You seem to be awful interested in him, maybe you should give Greg a call and see if he will sell you one of his offspring, never hurts to upgrade

Catch · Post by **Catch** » Fri Jun 20, 2008 2:39 am

Larry I have hunted with him and I have no interest in him or his offspring. JMO

larry · Post by **larry** » Fri Jun 20, 2008 2:54 am

Catch wrote:Larry I have hunted with him and I have no interest in him or his offspring. JMO

thats interesting seeing how most of the people with Greg's dogs seem to love em, and he is out of a pretty impressive stud in CodyII. To each his own

onalimb · Post by **onalimb** » Fri Jun 20, 2008 3:28 am

Mr. Drum, even though you own the site now, you still allow it's founder, "brian Barlow to cuss and insult others, and when they defend themselves like I did, they are banned. It seems things have not changed over there at all, Brian can take all the cheap shots he wants, but if myself or anybody else points out his faults, he can use the "F" word and any other thing he would like and get away with it, on your watch.

Publically I have challenged him to a private meeting, halfway between him and I, all he has to do is set a time and place!!!!!!!!!!!!!

He is a has been that never was, and that's all he'll ever be.

Catch · Post by **Catch** » Fri Jun 20, 2008 11:40 am

Preston how have you been? It has been a long time since we have talked. How hunting in the great state of Idaho?

Just a word of advice, becarfull how you talk about all the Experienced hunters on the Smithdeal site. You will receive a response like this one from Mr Drumm.

WHY DO YOU HIDE BEHIND MADE UP NAMES WHEN YOU POST STUFF LIKE YOU DO .. CONSTANTLY RUNNING DOWN OTHERS DOGS , THEIR DOGS HUNTING ABILTY ,THEIR OWN HUNTING ABILITY .. TALKING CRAP ABOUT THINGS YOU JUST KNOW NOTHING ABOUT ??
OR IF THE SMITHDEAL SITE IS SO BAD WHY HAVE YOU TRIED TO RE-REGISTER ?? STILL USING FAKE NAMES TO TRY TO DO SO ??

LOL.

Take Care

Dan Edwards · Post by **Dan Edwards** » Fri Jun 20, 2008 12:02 pm

I hunted with a female off of Cody II last weekend.